The future of the Athletics organization is bright, and the fans are buzzing with excitement as they shape the team’s prospect rankings. But here’s where it gets controversial: who truly deserves the ninth spot on this highly contested list? With Edgar Montero securing the eighth position through a fan vote, the spotlight now shifts to the next wave of talent. Montero, a switch-hitting shortstop signed internationally just last year, has impressed with his all-around skills, though scouts debate whether he’ll eventually move to third base as he matures. The A’s, however, are committed to developing him at shortstop, a bold move that underscores their faith in his potential.
And this is the part most people miss: the pipeline is brimming with talent, from the recently extended Jacob Wilson to the newest nominee, right-handed pitcher Cole Miller. Miller, a former fourth-round pick, missed his debut season due to Tommy John surgery but returned with a vengeance, showcasing a plus-fastball and promising secondary pitches. While he’s still years away from the majors, his upside has fans and scouts alike dreaming of what could be.
Here’s how the voting works—and it’s simpler than you think: Each round features a single winner, determined by the most votes, while the remaining players move to the next ballot alongside a new nominee. To nominate a player, simply reply to the ‘NOMINATIONS’ comment with their name. If a prospect is traded, their name is crossed out, and if a new player is acquired, a special vote determines their ranking. Easy, right?
Now, let’s dive into the current nominees for the ninth spot, each with their own unique story and potential:
Tommy White, 3B (Age: 22, Expected Level: Double-A)
White’s power is undeniable, with a bat that could carry him to the majors. While his defensive limitations may push him to first base, his ability to hit for both average and power makes him a standout. But here’s the question: Can he overcome his defensive shortcomings to become a cornerstone of the A’s offense?
Shotaro Morii, SS/RHP (Age: 19, Expected Level: Low-A)
Morii is a true two-way talent, excelling both at the plate and on the mound. His smooth left-handed swing and high-velocity fastball have fans dreaming of a Shohei Ohtani-like impact. But is it realistic to expect him to succeed in both roles, or will the A’s eventually force him to choose one?
Devin Taylor, OF (Age: 22, Expected Level: High-A)
Taylor’s offensive prowess is his calling card, with the potential to be a plus hitter for both average and power. However, his fringy defensive skills limit him to a corner outfield spot. Is his bat enough to make him a future star, or will his defensive limitations hold him back?
Steven Echavarria, RHP (Age: 20, Expected Level: Double-A)
Echavarria’s electric stuff, including a fastball that touches 98 mph, has the A’s excited. Despite control issues in 2025, the organization remains patient, believing in his long-term potential as a starter. Can he regain the command that made him a standout before the draft, or will his struggles persist?
Cole Miller, RHP (Age: 20, Expected Level: Single-A)
Miller’s return from injury has been nothing short of impressive, with a dominant 1.90 ERA in his first pro season. His 6-foot-6 frame and three-pitch mix scream workhorse starter. But after such a strong debut, can he sustain this momentum and climb the ranks quickly?
The voting continues, and the debate rages on. Who do you think deserves the ninth spot? And more importantly, which of these players has the potential to become the next face of the Athletics? Let us know in the comments—we’re eager to hear your take!
